Israeli Home Shopping Channel offered A Special Offer To Consumers, Only To End Up With A "Great Deal" For Itself
By
Shay Rosemberg
*
Who among us was not tempted, at least
once, to pick up the phone and dial the number that appears on the television
screen, offering a limited, and a very seductive chance to seize a once in a
lifetime opportunity.
Be
honest… we have all been there, late at night, alone in the living room,
changing channels so our minds will wind down, city sounds already a distant
memory since all are fast asleep, and then… the home shopping channel. Our
finger still on the remote, as if our sub conscious screams from within that we
should change a channel. But night had overcome sensibility, and we allow
ourselves to indulge in a few minutes of TV produced marketing.
Such
was the case for an Israeli man who was watching the Israeli home shopping
channel only to witness what he considered as a great offer for a great deal.
Special
Sale! were the words that came across the screen. An adjustable bed which,
according to the information that appeared on screen, was valued at around 17,000
NIS (New Israeli Shekel) (about 4,700 USD), but the home shopping channel was
offering, for a limited time of Twenty-Four hours only, the same bed for only
5,000 NIS (about 1,400 USD).
The
viewer phoned his parents, knowing they were looking to purchase a new bed, and
followed the special offer and the time constraints attached to it, they
purchased the bed. Alas, the parents were disillusioned, and the son did not
receive the Best Son award. As the movers carried the bed into the
parents’ apartment, the quality of the bed raised concerns with the purchasers
that this was no 17,000 NIS bed. A short enquiry with the bed’s manufacturer
revealed a disconcerting fact as the manufacturer stated, we never manufactured
any 17,000 NIS beds.
Following
that incident, it was revealed that the home shopping channel was, in fact,
using this clever technique on multiple items that are marketed as Special
Offers for a Limited Time Only. The Purchasers filed for a class action
lawsuit, stating a fraudulent misrepresentation claim, bad faith conduct, violation
of Consumer Protection Law and negligence.
The
District Court in Tel Aviv allowed for the class action lawsuit, while defining
the group of individuals affected by the defendant’s actions as: all people who
had purchased any items from the home shopping channel in the past seven years,
and which those items were marketed as “special offers” despite never being
marketed in considerable higher price.
The
claim also stated breach of one’s autonomy, stating the lack of ability to
reach an educated decision concerning the purchase of the product, either in
general or from the channel specifically.
The
Court, allowing for the case to be filed as a class action lawsuit, stated that
presenting a price that reflects nearly one third of an amount that never
actually existed, was a fictitious sale which violates the consumer protection
law; a law that is designed to protect consumers by implementing certain restrictions,
the foremost being to disclose as much information as possible so that the
consumer will be well informed of the transaction he is getting himself into.
Despite
all, the lawsuit was settled, and the Israeli home shopping channel paid NIS4.5
million and agreed to cease such actions that might reflect special offers
that do not exist. When all is said and done and based on the intolerance the Israeli
courts have towards business which manipulate consumers, it would appear that
the Israeli home shopping channel was the one that got the great deal.
The case number is 7494-09-13 Ester
Bashan v. K.Y.D Shopping Channel Ltd.
* Shay
Rosemberg is an Israeli and New-York Attorney who specializes in International Law, corporate & commercial Law, Real-Estate, Taxation.
Comments
Post a Comment