MERGING SAFELY WITH THE ISRAELI BUSINESS ARENA
By
Shay Rosenberg
*
“Are
Israeli and American law and legal system even similar?”
Often
that is the line that surfaces whenever the person who is sitting in front of
me learns that I dabble both within the Israeli halls of justice, as well as within
the American ones.
When it comes to Israeli law, American
clients need more attention, I once said to one of my clients, an American
real-estate investor who had started an Israeli corporation with the purpose of
locating and purchasing lucrative real-estate assets in the Holy Land. His look
of distain, which insinuated that I was discriminating between American and Israeli
clients, as if implying that American clients are not as savvy as Israeli ones,
made me realize how unaware is the average American businessman to the complexity
which surrounds Israeli law.
Today,
I am not ashamed to admit that our firm allocates more of its resources and
time to better prepare the average American who decides to enter the Israeli
arena, then the Israeli client who is about to enter the American one. The
reason is quite simple; American law is not as unpredictable as the Israeli.
Understanding
the Difference
American
law and culture is based on the promise for individuality and freedom of
choice. The rights of one to do as he pleases, providing his actions would not
inflict harm on the greater good. Even the federal government’s power to
exercise control in and among states is extremely limited by the constitution.
Laws, regulations, and even Judicial interpretation will always reflect those
ideals as it furthers the ideology that goes hand in hand with those principles.
Israel
is somewhat different. A country established in haste, accomplishing the
unimaginable while staving off the unthinkable. Its army was born from multiple
militias which, on the eve of the nation, still fought each other instead of
its enemies. Its infrastructure based on improvisations which later became
worldwide leading innovations. An origin story that dates back to biblical
settings, only to be redesigned small fragments at a time, and from all corners
of the globe.
David
Ben-Gurion, the immortal figure and standard that is engraved within the soul
of the Israeli nation, once said that he cared not about the political ideology
that would steer Israel, nor even the personal perceptions that would accompany
those who settle in the Holy Land (paraphrasing, of course). All he wanted was
as many Jews as possible to come home and help establish the State of Israel.
Not
surprising, the majority of the Jews who answered the call, came from today’s
Eastern Europe states and the former Soviet Union, where ideology and economic
perceptions were more socialist-oriented. Naturally, this was a direct
influence on the emerging Israeli conception of social norms, governmental
norms, and of course… Legislative and Judicial norms.
If
you were to browse the early case laws of the Israeli Supreme Court, you will
undoubtedly notice the traces of socialism laced between the lines that
prescribed Justice and interpretational law.
So
what does that got to do with the difference between American and Israeli law
and legal systems?
The
residuals of socialism are still enclaved within Israeli law and case laws.
Some grew into regulations, some developed into perceptions and some even claimed
their status as social norms. They are perceived as the obvious to most
Israelis, and yet… as impossible or illogical norms to most Americans.
Blinded
by the success of the Israeli real-estate corporation the he started only two
years ago, my American client, the same one who did not appreciate my remark on
allocating more attention to American clients over Israelis, encountered the gap
(or should I say precipice) which lay between the two legal systems, when he
terminated the employment of one of his employees.
The
term at will employment, which entitles an employer to terminate the
employment of an employee with no just cause, does not exist in Israel, and its
core concept is something that any Israeli employee would view as a detrimental
violation of his legal rights. So imagine a scenario in which an American
employer fires an Israeli employee in Israel. The American would consider the
termination as exercising a very basic right, yet the Israeli would view the
termination as a pending law suit against his employer.
Israeli
labor law and case law prevents the employer from firing an employee with no
just cause, and even then, the employer must go through a certain ritual
(I use the word “ritual” carefully since the Israeli labor court insisted in
recent years that firing an employee need not be a ceremony, just show good
faith and fairness). What do I mean by ritual?
First,
the employer must deliver a summons prior to holding a hearing. The summons
must outline the employer’s intention and reasons for considering termination
(note the word “considering”). Second, the summons must be given with
reasonable advance time to prepare (Israeli labor law determined that reasonable
is Two to Three days prior to the hearing). The employee may be accompanied by
a representative/attorney during the hearing, and must be given a proper chance
to rebut to the allegations that were set in the summons.
One
might believe that this would suffice and the employer would now be free to
terminate the employment of the employee, but now social responsibility kicks
in, and if the employee had been employed for a full year or more (in certain
cases even if only eleven months), than the employer must pay the employee one-month’s-pay
+ termination fee (one-month’s-pay times the years of
employment).
But
wait, it does not end here, since usually that is the moment when the employee
would begin searching for all sorts of “errors” that the employer had neglected
to notice during employment, such as pension payments, required by Israeli law
to be deducted from the employee’s salary on a monthly basis and deposited in a
pension fund. To deduct a pension fee from the employee’s salary and not to
deposit it into the pension fund is tantamount to stealing and is considered a
criminal offense in the state of Israel.
“But
this is insane!” my client
screamed as he struggled to wrap his mind around this absurd list of
requirements. “You’re telling me I can’t fire someone in my own company?!”
The
answer is yes, you can fire an employee, but you have to conduct the
termination procedure in total compliance to Israeli labor law.
What
you have read here today is the basic outline for a proper procedure, yet
circumstances may very well change the required procedure and tilt the scale so
that the law would suddenly in favor the employer and not the employee.
For instance,
if an employee is suspected in using company’s assets illegally, or acting on
his own or someone else’s interest, the employer would have considerable leeway
to take necessary steps to protect his own. In certain cases, the employer
would be entitled for compensatory damages from the employee.
This
working man protection grid, that was created part by Israeli legislators
and part by the Israeli Judiciary system, is without a doubt a remnant of a
social norm that was instilled in the first waves of Jewish immigrants from the
former Soviet nations. Socialism has branded its mark on Israel, and although Israel
had managed to reinvent itself with modern perceptions, it still hides legal
mines throughout its legal system.
As
for my client, who finally realized that American clients were indeed more
susceptible for legal entanglements that might occur from the most simple of
things when dealing with Israeli day-to-day legal culture, he and his company
are now kept regularly updated for every new legal minutiae that Israeli law
has instore for the world, merging safely… with the booming Israeli business arena.
* Shay
Rosenberg is an Israeli Attorney who specializes in International, corporate
and commercial Law, Real-Estate, Taxation.
You can contact us at office@rosbrolaw.com
Comments
Post a Comment