Skip to main content

THREE THE MAGIC NUMBER


THE NEW PROPERTY TAXATION IN ISRAEL
By
Shay Rosenberg*

On October 22nd, 2016, the Knesset (Israeli Parliament) approved the Economic Streamlining Law (legislation amendments for obtaining budget agendas for 2017-2018), in which a whole section was devoted for a new property taxation on individuals who own at the very least two and a half residential properties (249% ownership) within the state of Israel.

            Israel is well known for its Startup Nation reputation, luring hundreds if not thousands of foreign investors worldwide. Yet Startup companies are not the only investing angle that the land of milk and honey has to offer. Recent years have revealed Israel to be a gold mine in the real-estate realm, enjoying an approximate 11% steady annual incline in property value and full investment return via rent, in some locals, within a period of just a few years.

            Most foreign investors treaded smartly as they established Israeli corporations and purchased various property holdings throughout the holy land, while others used their Israeli Passports or a relative resident to purchase the properties on their behalf. The returns streamed in, the investors grew richer, and for some, Israel’s booming real-estate farm reminded them of the happy days prior to 2008’s bubble. But despite the grim prophecies, in which Israel’s real-estate market will collapse, made by dozens of financial prophets who just can’t seem to get it right in the past nine years, property prices kept soaring and owners kept smiling.

            But every fairytale must have an overdramatic villain who would stop at nothing until the people of the happy kingdom will suffer. In this case, the villain came in various forms, from unorganized protests against rising property prices and on to political figures cloaked under the guise of a financial Messiah.

Recent attempts to thwart the steady increase in real-estate value came under the guiding hand of the Minister of Finance (equivalent to Secretary of Treasury) Moshe Kahlon, who desperately seeks to prove himself as an influential figure in the Israeli government (no doubt in order to lay the foundation for future political gains, such as the position he craved in recent elections of Prime Minister). Kahlon based his candidacy in the last elections on the promise to lower housing prices and subdue the rising property value, a promise that came not only to haunt him, but came to haunt most of those who own more than two apartments in Israel.

It was unofficially named The Third Apartment Tax, which will apply only on those who own two and a half residential apartments (249% ownership). The tax will constitute 1% of the total value of one of the apartments that the owner so chooses. If the owner owns the apartment in common, he will pay according to his percentage in the ownership. The tax, however, will not exceed NIS18,000 per year (roughly about USD4,700 per year).

The value of the taxed apartment, and consequently the tax to be paid, will be calculated via a mathematical formula which will take into account the square feet of the apartment and its location (for instance, a 400 sq. ft apartment in the city of Tel Aviv will carry higher value and thus a higher tax than a similar sized apartment in the city of Netanya).

Corporations that are owned by five individuals (a person and his relative are counted as one) are also subject to the new tax if own more than two apartments. And if you thought you were lucky because you own three apartments that are used for commercial purposes (i.e., office, store, warehouse etc.), those also are subject to the new tax if the apartment was primarily designated as residential.

The rationale behind this law is one that can only be ascribed to socialism rather than any substantive financial or even political motivation. The idea is to bring about the “release” of thousands of residential properties back into the market rather than allowing them to be used for monetary gains by their owners. In essence, Minister Kahlon is hoping that all property owners that own more than two apartments will sell their third, thus increasing supply vs. demand which will result in a substantial decrease in housing prices.

So, should all those who own property in the State of Israel pounce in terror and sell off their property holdings (if more than two apartments) before suffering any financial losses?

The answer is a resounding NO!

The reasons for said answer range from the possible legal and fundamental rights infringement in lieu of the new taxation law, which is currently debated in the Israeli Supreme Court, and on to possible countermeasures that most apartment owners have already begun to implement in order to hinder any upcoming losses.

I will spare you the broad and specific explanation as to a possible violation of legal and fundamental rights. Suffice it to say that the Israeli Supreme court is considering the fact that the Third Apartment Tax might violate the fundamental right of ownership, since being taxed merely because you were fortunate enough to purchase more than two apartments in order to live of the rent in your old age, cripples one of Israel’s Basic Laws (legally equivalent to Constitutional laws and considered as lex terrae – High law of the land). That law is Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty, which via the Israeli Supreme Court’s decision, also guarantees various fundamental rights derived from said law. The only question that stands before the Supreme Court now is whether the violation is severe enough to trigger a judicial veto to abolish the Third Apartment Tax.

But the Supreme Court does not only have to clear the matter of constitutionality with regard to the new tax, but also clear the accusations pertaining to the legislation process which led to the new taxation law, and which was proven to be procedurally flawed. Six petitions were filed in the Israeli Supreme Court against the new tax, and now a whole country is waiting for the next Court hearing that will take place on March 23rd, and in which the State will have to convince the Court to allow the law to survive even though it was conceived without proper procedures.

What was achieved thus far? The law provided for all third apartment owners to file a statement accounting all of their real-estate property to the Israeli Tax Authority no later than March 31st, 2017. However, due to the multiple petitions and uncertainty created by the Court’s intervention, the Israeli Tax Authority has released a statement amending the filing date to no later than June 30, 2017.

In the meantime… most of the property owners maintain poise and serenity, not because they have faith that the Israeli Supreme Court will remand the new tax law back to the Knesset for adjustments or scrap, but because most of them had already begun adjusting the rent to compensate any future taxes. So if the current rent on a NIS1.8 million apartment is NIS4,200 per month, most landlords have already notified their tenants of a NIS800-NIS1,000 increase at the end of the lease period.

The outcome of the Third Apartment Tax Law might be completely different from what Minister Kahlon had intended, since an increase in rent would also increase property value. And since the new tax is limited to no more than NIS18,000 per year, increasing the rent would negate any serious losses to the owners. The Israeli real-estate market might be facing a sharp rise in property value within a very short time span.

Most investors seek the perfect investment, and in Israel the innovations and the creativity of the new generations are the allure and charm that procreate the promise of not only a better tomorrow, but of millions if not billions of dollars in return. But alongside it all, there sits the piece of land that promises no less, and despite multiple attempts to slow or retract the rising value and returns of the Israeli real-estate realm, it continues to fight off any obstructions and lives up to its name of the holy land, proving to people like Moshe Kahlon that three... is not always a magic number.

 

* Shay Rosenberg is an Israeli Attorney who specializes in International Law, International Contracts, International Taxation, Real-Estate and Corporate Law.

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

BACK TO THE (LEGAL) FUTURE

POSSIBLE LEGAL RAMIFICATIONS IN LIEU OF THE AUTONOMOUS CARS By Shay Rosenberg* One of the benefits of being an attorney who is also married to attorney, is the legal discussions that come up every once in a while, usually in a desperate attempt by my wife to outsmart me with regards to some legal issue that I failed to notice or pay any heed to. It almost became a weekly ritual during our lives, in which my wife believes that she will finally have me cornered, when I prove to her time and time again that today will not be that day. This ritual ended a few days ago, when my wife brought up an intriguing legal question, for which, I must confess, I had no definitive answer, but only a speculative one. I of course will protect my honor by explaining that the issue she brought up had not yet fully formulated in society’s everyday life, and therefore no real attention should have been vested in the matter, but that would be wrong, since the subject is on society’s doorstep, and s...

ISRAELI LABOR LAW PAIN

MERGING SAFELY WITH THE ISRAELI BUSINESS ARENA By Shay Rosenberg * “Are Israeli and American law and legal system even similar?” Often that is the line that surfaces whenever the person who is sitting in front of me learns that I dabble both within the Israeli halls of justice, as well as within the American ones.             When it comes to Israeli law, American clients need more attention , I once said to one of my clients, an American real-estate investor who had started an Israeli corporation with the purpose of locating and purchasing lucrative real-estate assets in the Holy Land. His look of distain, which insinuated that I was discriminating between American and Israeli clients, as if implying that American clients are not as savvy as Israeli ones, made me realize how unaware is the average American businessman to the complexity which surrounds Israeli law. Today, I am not ashamed to admit that our firm ...