POSSIBLE LEGAL RAMIFICATIONS IN LIEU OF THE AUTONOMOUS CARS
By
Shay Rosenberg*
By
Shay Rosenberg*
One of the benefits of being an attorney who is also married to
attorney, is the legal discussions that come up every once in a while, usually
in a desperate attempt by my wife to outsmart me with regards to some legal
issue that I failed to notice or pay any heed to. It almost became a weekly
ritual during our lives, in which my wife believes that she will finally have
me cornered, when I prove to her time and time again that today will not be
that day.
This ritual ended a few days ago, when my wife brought up an
intriguing legal question, for which, I must confess, I had no definitive
answer, but only a speculative one. I of course will protect my honor by
explaining that the issue she brought up had not yet fully formulated in
society’s everyday life, and therefore no real attention should have been
vested in the matter, but that would be wrong, since the subject is on
society’s doorstep, and should be broached as soon as possible.
Before I address the issue at hand, I would like to begin with a
short preface that would explain my sudden interest that led to this article.
Israel, 2014, the government had finally enacted a set of
regulations for the use of an electric bicycle, which was very widely used in
the years which preceded that year, during which hundreds of pedestrians were
injured without any real chance of compensation as a result of a legal chaos
which engulfed the electric bicycle trend.
In the State of Israel, a bicycle enjoys very few regulatory
sanctions. The main ones are the requirements for a helmet, and the prohibition
of riding on sidewalks. This is in large due to the fact that a bicycle is not
considered as a Motorized Vehicle, as defined by the Israeli
Transportation Mandatory Directive, which states that a motorized vehicle
is “a vehicle propelled by a mechanical power of any kind, including a
scooter and a motorcycle…”
One might raise the obvious question of why is then that an electric
bicycle does not fall within the category of a motorized vehicle, since it is
without a doubt propelled by a mechanical power (the Battery). Well, the
Israeli Supreme Court disagrees. In the case of Davey Shforen v. Jack Turgeman,
it was determined that a “Mechanical Scooter” does not answer the legal
definition as set in the Mandatory Directive, since it is constructed primarily
as a toy and not a transportation vehicle, as well as the fact that its maximum
speed is approx. 19 mph.
But eventually, after years of legal turmoil and countless victims
of a speedy bicycle that was not considered a vehicle, and thus did not allow
for compensation under various laws, a new set of rules and regulations were
enacted to protect the public interests, define responsibilities as well as guidelines,
and create a basis for claims arising from tort law, liability etc. In short,
the State of Israel realized the new reality and all the possible situations
that went along with it, and adapted accordingly.
This summarized example, is the best equivalent to what the entire
world will have to deal with in the coming years in light of the latest
advancements in humanity’s everyday life.
Most of the Science fiction movies portray the future as a
neon-lighted setting, with flying cars hovering in the background, but the
truth of the matter, at least for now, is that the future is one that resembles
a more opaque version of that being displayed to us in Hollywood, a version in
which technology and legal advancements must go hand in hand, just like the
motorized bicycle example. To deny this suggested but very realistic link,
would be only to delay the inevitable, which is that the courts and legislators
will have to address the newest of technologies and define them and their use.
In steps the crazy notion and newest advancement of technology; the
autonomous car (also referred to as “the driverless car”), which to this very
day has yet to be addressed properly by any legal system in the
world (except a few states which gave a very general welcome to the idea of
having self-driving cars in order to assume the look of progressing and
achieving countries, i.e. political goals), and yet had already been announced
and even legalized in various states and countries.
I will dispense with any technical descriptions that might have
been expected by some of you, albeit the technical background of the autonomous
cars is the basis for this article, and I shall stick to the basic description
that is already self-explained by the title of the product; autonomous car. So
how does a car steer itself in city streets and highways? Simple…
GPS + Radar + Special Cameras + Motions Sensors + Laser Scanner +
Speed Sensor
Combined with a sophisticated processing unit… and you have an Autonomous Car.
On May 2013, the NHTSA (US National Highway Traffic Safety
Administration) released its policy on automated vehicles, and in it a
classification chart to define the level of autonomous vehicles:
No-Automation (Level 0): The
driver is in complete and sole control of the primary vehicle controls – brake,
steering, throttle, and motive power – at all times.
Function-specific Automation (Level 1): Automation at this level involves one or more specific
control functions. Examples include electronic stability control or pre-charged
brakes, where the vehicle automatically assists with braking to enable the
driver to regain control of the vehicle or stop faster than possible by acting
alone.
Combined Function Automation (Level 2): This level involves automation of at least two primary
control functions designed to work in unison to relieve the driver of control
of those functions. An example of combined functions enabling a Level 2 system
is adaptive cruise control in combination with lane centering.
Limited Self-Driving Automation (Level 3): Vehicles at this level of automation enable the driver to
cede full control of all safety-critical functions under certain traffic or
environmental conditions and in those conditions to rely heavily on the vehicle
to monitor for changes in those conditions requiring transition back to driver
control. The driver is expected to be available for occasional control, but
with sufficiently comfortable transition time. The Google car is an example of
limited self-driving automation.
Full Self-Driving Automation (Level 4): The vehicle is designed to perform all safety-critical
driving functions and monitor roadway conditions for an entire trip. Such a
design anticipates that the driver will provide destination or navigation
input, but is not expected to be available for control at any time during the
trip. This includes both occupied and unoccupied vehicles.
For the first time the future was no longer science fiction, but
actual science that was to be integrated in our lives, and more specifically,
in our most vulnerable place; our roads.
I remember a line that my father told me the day I received my
driver’s license, “Driving a car is no less dangerous than holding a loaded
weapon. Both can take a person’s life if used recklessly.” I imagine that line
echoes in my mind even today when I get behind the wheel of my car, but that
exact line also echoed when my wife raised the issue of liability in case of an
autonomous car accident.
When a person steers the car, he is held liable for any accident
that might occur due to his performance as a driver, but when a computer steers
the vehicle, who is there to blame?
Even if proper laws would be introduced, the courts will have to
interpret the fine line between human error, and a computer glitch.
On May 7th, 2016, a an automated Tesla model S Electric
car crashed with an 18-wheel tractor-trailer, while in self-driving mode,
causing the death of the test driver which was seated in the autonomous car.
This is the first known fatal accident involving the autonomous car, and
Tesla’s explanation was that the car failed to notice the white side of the
tractor-trailer against the brightly lit sky, thus failing to engage the
breaks.
This incident should have made most of the lawmakers in the world
think… who is to be blamed, and who is to be held liable. Should the test
driver be held liable as an existing person in the car? I mean, he could have
remained alerted and apply the brakes as he noticed the tractor-trailer
approaching. Or should the legal system blame Tesla, for allowing a test drive
before even inspecting all possible scenarios within the safety of a computer
lab? How about the programmer who created the software which identifies
obstacles? Or the company which manufactured the laser sensors for being too
narrow to spot incoming vehicles?
The list goes on and on, and only settles at the obvious; there is
no definitive answer.
And let us contemplate on the notion that a driver is in the
vehicle, and therefore capable of assuming control of the machine in case of
emergency, thus preventing disaster. Where do we draw that imaginary line in
which we claim the driver’s liability? Is it from the moment the driver steps
into his autonomous car? This will negate the entire idea of self-driving. What
is the level of awareness that a driver must have in order to avoid any
liability charges should the car impact something or someone?
If a child surprisingly jumps into the street as an autonomous car
passes by, and the vehicles fails to respond in time, who is to blame? Will the
courts accept the data from the car’s sensors without hesitation?
In 2011, Nevada became the first state ever to legally allow the
operation of autonomous cars on public roads. Its legislators defined an
autonomous car as “a motor vehicle that uses artificial intelligence,
sensors and global positioning system coordinates to drive itself without the
active intervention of a human operator”. It also specifically resigns with
the fact that the driver of such vehicle is exempt from paying any attention as
the car self-drives. This definition is one which transfers full liability to a
software, thus eliminating the human factor and excluding it from any legal
entanglements.
In 2016, California, Florida, Michigan, Hawaii, Washington,
Tennessee, and the District of Columbia, had enacted laws to govern the
autonomous cars notion. From 2013 to 2015, the UK, France and Switzerland had
also joined to allow autonomous cars on public roads, and in essence verifying
the inescapable truth, that autonomous cars are already here. Yet despite all
the minor legislation that took place, no real legal preparation ever took
place with regards to the dangers that lurk behind progress.
In an article by John Greenough from June 15, 2016, published on
the Business Insider, an approximated number of 10 Million autonomous
cars will be steering themselves on public roads. It is my personal opinion
that an international effort should be put into play immediately, in order to
create a set international rules and regulations for the autonomous car, if not
from the mere possibility that in today’s world, a terrorist attack which puts
an autonomous car in use is not such a crazy idea, and a well-structured legal
fence could keep that danger at bay.
An international legal team that will construct the legal
definitions and regulations for the transportation of the 21st
century will have quite a challenge. It will encounter a legal realm that no
lawmaker had ever encountered before. In his paper, “Legal Aspects of
Autonomous Driving”, Dr, Sven A. Beiker suggested a checklist that might
assist for the preparation of a litigation in the field of the autonomous car.
I consider this list to be an integral part of what is proposed here. The most
important elements in the above mentioned checklist, for a legal prep, are in
my opinion:
-
Mock trials and focus groups.
-
Special
insurance policies for autonomous vehicles.
-
Mandatory
data recorders for autonomous vehicles.
Legal structures, legal systems, legal enforcement… are all tools
that could prepare us to battle not only day to day disputes regarding a
fender-bender which took place sue to a faulty computer chip, but could also
prepare us for the worst of the worst, and for that which we try to dismiss.
So How will the future seem like, I ask when I picture the obvious
scenario in which my car drives itself to the parking lot as I enter the
restaurant with my astute wife, oblivious to the fact that my car could injure
a pedestrian which decides to cross the road unexpectedly. Law is the one
profession that has no age. It was here since even before the Ten Commandments,
and yet it survived through time by matching itself to the present. In the
words of former Israeli Chief Justice, Aharon Barak, in what I consider to be
my favorite quote, “It is the role of any judge in a democratic society to
interpret the law in accordance to present day standards, in essence, become a
bridge between what the legislators had in mind and what present day society
is.”
But this situation, as explained throughout this article, is not one
that any legislator had set its tone for. This is one of the few creations that
lawmakers will have to deal with from scratch. No previous precedents, no legal
background, no technical knowledge on what is wrong, and what is right. Unlike the
notion of genetic manipulation and cloning, which in a certain sense was
governed by the laws of nature prior to its worldy legislation, the notion of a
machine conducting life risking decisions is one that lawmakers had yet to
encounter, and as mentioned above, in this writer’s opinion, should be addressed
immediately.
Perhaps it is with the words of George Santayana, which were later
quoted by Winston Churchill himself that I should end this article: “Those
who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” But that would be
too dramatic, so I chose to end with a saying from the famous Back to the
Future Trilogy: “…the future is whatever you make of it…” and it is my
hope that lawmakers all around the globe will start working on a bright one.
* Shay Rosenberg is an Israeli Attorney who specializes in International Law, International Contracts, International Taxation, Real-Estate and Corporate Law. He is a Founding Partner at the Law offices of RBA - Attorneys At Law (Israel).
* Shay Rosenberg is an Israeli Attorney who specializes in International Law, International Contracts, International Taxation, Real-Estate and Corporate Law. He is a Founding Partner at the Law offices of RBA - Attorneys At Law (Israel).
Comments
Post a Comment